Jamiat-e-Ulema protests against SIR, removal of mosque loudspeakers in Bengal; here's how SIR helped keep illegal Bangladeshis away from voting

West Bengal Chief Minister Suvendu Adhikari on May 20th announced the implementation of a mechanism under which infiltrators detained by state police would be handed over directly to the BSF for deportation, while unveiling what he described as part of a broader "detect, delete and deport" framework.

NewsBharati    12-Aug-2026 13:13:30 PM   
Total Views |
Even after the West Bengal Assembly elections, the row over SIR (Special Intensive Revision) continues unabated. On Tuesday, August 11, the West Bengal unit of Jamiat-e-Ulema staged a protest march opposing what it called the 'disproportionate deletion of 27 lakh voters' names during the Special Intensive Revision (SIR), along with the removal of loudspeakers from mosques. The march was conducted after the Calcutta High Court granted permission for the procession, overturning Kolkata Police's earlier refusal.
 
SIR 

Leading the march was state president Maulana Siddiqullah Chowdhury, who also aimed at the removal of loudspeakers from mosques, accusing the RSS of turning the matter into a political "drama." "Tell the Chief Minister that there are huge, four-foot speakers. If he has the courage, let him remove them. He does not have the courage to do so. They are simply putting on this drama," Chowdhury said, dismissing it as "a drama, a show by the RSS."

Chowdhury also said that through SIR, the names of lakhs of Muslims in Bengal had been struck off the voter list. "People are now running from pillar to post to the tribunal to get their names added back to the voter list, but no hearings are taking place there," Chowdhury said, adding that a tribunal office should be opened in every district, and disputes should be resolved in a time-bound manner. He warned that if the Election Commission does not accept this demand, the people of Bengal will not stay silent.
 
 

Interestingly, it is important to note that the Calcutta High Court had, on Monday, permitted Jamiat-e-Ulema to hold a rally, subject to certain conditions. The Court had allowed the organization to take out a rally from Rajabazar to the Maulali area on Tuesday, between 11:30 am and 1 pm. The High Court had stated that a maximum of 750 people could participate in the rally; however, more than 1000s of Islamists could be seen participating in the rally.
 

It may also be noted that on the SIR issue, Congress leader Adhir Ranjan Chowdhury has approached the Supreme Court. On his appeal, the Supreme Court has directed the Election Commission to file a detailed reply. The Court has asked the Election Commission how many cases the tribunal has resolved so far, and what steps the Commission has taken to expedite this process. Adhir Ranjan Chowdhury said that after the Supreme Court's intervention, he now has renewed hope for justice.

Removal of loudspeakers from the Mosques irked Islamists

The said rally comes days after the West Bengal Police, on August 6 across several districts in the state, began asking mosque committees to remove high-decibel rooftop loudspeakers and replace them with sound boxes. This follows the newly elected BJP government's decision to strictly enforce existing noise pollution norms at religious places.

Urban Development Minister Agnimitra Paul clarified later that the drive was not directed at any particular religious community. She said the Cabinet's decision applies equally to all religious institutions, including temples, mosques and other places of worship, and that no one will be allowed to violate the prescribed noise pollution norms.
 

Industry Minister Tapas Roy also stated that the government would appeal to all religious institutions to voluntarily comply with the regulations. However, the implementation drew criticism from several Muslim organisations, which argued that the law regulated noise levels rather than mandating the removal of loudspeakers.

SIR for elimination of illegal Bangladeshi immigrants vs Islamist allegations

The Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls in West Bengal has been a routine, constitutionally mandated exercise aimed at cleaning up voter lists, not at targeting any community, as clarified by the Election Commission several times in the past. The drive was specifically designed to identify and remove ineligible, illegal entries, including names of non-citizens, particularly those alleged to be undocumented immigrants from Bangladesh who may have entered voter rolls over the years through fraudulent documentation.
 

Opposition parties and groups like Jamiat Ulema-e-Hind, however, claim that the process disproportionately affected genuine Indian citizens, particularly Muslims, with claims of lakhs of legitimate voters being wrongly struck off. This dispute is currently before the Supreme Court, which has sought a detailed response from the EC.

Illegal Bangladeshis agreed that they were provided fraudulent documents by TMC

It is important to note that the illegal immigration from neighboring Bangladesh has created serious demographic, economic, and security challenges in the border districts of the state of West Bengal in the past few years. The earlier government led by the All India Trinamool Congress was pursuing vote-bank politics by allegedly turning a blind eye to undocumented migration and weak border enforcement.
 
 

During the recently held West Bengal elections, several Bangladeshi Islamists confessed that the former TMC government provided them with key documents and cash under the Lakshmi Bhandar scheme for their votes.

"I made a ration card, a voter card when Mamata's party was there. The party's grassroots workers helped us get the cards in exchange for votes. We also voted in the Indian elections 2024 after being offered Lakshmi Bhandar benefits," one of the immigrants could be heard saying.
 

Another illegal immigrant also revealed that his father voted for TMC after the party workers arranged for illegal Indian ID cards. This is a day after large numbers of illegal Bangladeshi migrants began congregating at several border points across West Bengal, as the BJP government's newly launched "detect, delete and deport" policy moved from political announcement to ground-level implementation.

West Bengal's "detect, delete and deport" framework

West Bengal Chief Minister Suvendu Adhikari on May 20th announced the implementation of a mechanism under which infiltrators detained by state police would be handed over directly to the BSF for deportation, while unveiling what he described as part of a broader "detect, delete and deport" framework.
 
ALSO READ: Detect, Delete, Deport: WB CM Adhikari says those not covered under CAA will be termed infiltrators and deported immediately, details 

The announcement signalled a sharper policy turn on infiltration and border management, long among the BJP's most potent political themes in Bengal, at the centre of the new government's agenda. Adhikari said those communities covered under the Citizenship (Amendment) Act (CAA) would remain outside the ambit of the new mechanism, while others identified as infiltrators would face action with immediate effect.

In the given case, the court has fixed August 25 as the next date of hearing on Adhir Ranjan Chowdhury's petition.

Siddhi Somani

Siddhi Somani is known for her satirical and factual hand in Economic, Social and Political writing. Having completed her post graduation in Journalism, she is currently engaged in completing her Masters in Politics. The author meanwhile is also exploring her hand in analytics and statistics.